Buy a $30 Gift Card and get a FREE $5 Gift Card until the end of 2022

1872 Cafe
visit: 431 w main st
call: 585-323-1872

1872 Cafe visit: 431 w main st call: 585-323-1872 1872 Cafe visit: 431 w main st call: 585-323-1872 1872 Cafe visit: 431 w main st call: 585-323-1872
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Order Online
  • Retail
  • Events Calendar
  • Photos
  • Contact Us
  • More
    • Home
    • Menu
    • Order Online
    • Retail
    • Events Calendar
    • Photos
    • Contact Us

1872 Cafe
visit: 431 w main st
call: 585-323-1872

1872 Cafe visit: 431 w main st call: 585-323-1872 1872 Cafe visit: 431 w main st call: 585-323-1872 1872 Cafe visit: 431 w main st call: 585-323-1872
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Order Online
  • Retail
  • Events Calendar
  • Photos
  • Contact Us

Menu

Coffee and More

We proudly serve Evening Star Coffee, roasted locally in Avon, NY! All our drinks are gluten-free and can be made Vegan upon request!

Drip Coffee

12oz: $1.95 / 16oz: $2.45 / 20oz: $2.75 / 24oz 3.10

Choose between our:

  • Bold Peruvian (darker) Roast
  • Medium house Roast
  • Flavor of the Day  (hint: MWF is pistachio)
  • House Blend Decaf
  • Make any drip coffee a red-eye + $ 0.75 !

Hot Bar

12 / 16 / 20 / 24oz

  • Cappuccino  $3.35 / $3.65 / 3.85 / 4.15
  • Latte  $3.45 / $3.75 / 3.95 / 4.25
  • Mocha  $3.75 / $3.95 / $4.25 / $4.55
  • Macchiato  $3.45 / $3.75 / 3.95 / 4.25
  • Americano $2.25 / $2.75 / $3.00 / $3.50
  • Cafe au Lait $2.50 / $2.95 / $3.25 / $3.75


Espresso

1.50/2.25

Fresh Ground Espresso

  • Make any drip coffee a red-eye add $0.75 !
  • Espresso Shot - Double $2.25

Undertow Shot 

  • Choice of flavor, cream, and fresh espresso $2.00 single shot or $3.00 double shot


Cold Bar

16oz / 20oz / 24oz

  • Iced Coffee $2.25/$2.50
  • Iced Latte $3.55/$3.85
  • Iced Mocha $4.25/$4.55
  • Iced Macchiato $4.25/$4.55

Specialty Drinks

16oz/20oz

Can be made hot or Iced cold!

  • Eleanor Roosevelt $4.55/$4.85
    • Breve style latte flavored with cinnamon and vanilla
  • Ella Fitzgerald $4.55/$4.85
    • Latte flavored with spicy ginger and sweet praline topped with a sprinkle of cinnamon
  • Maya Rudolph $4.75/$5.05
    • Mocha latte with sweet hazelnut topped with whipped cream

 

Teas

2.25/2.75

16oz/20oz

  • English Breakfast
  • Earl Grey
  • Chai (unsweet, leaves)
  • Green
  • Assorted Decaf Herbal Teas

Can be made hot or over ice!

Special-TEA Drinks

16oz/20oZor 24oz

Can be made hot or cold!

  • Sweet Chai Latte $3.65/$3.95

                   Sweet chai with your milk choice

  • Choose from Rio flavors
  • Tiger (sweet & regular) 
  • Orca (S
  • Tortoise
  • Flamingo
  • Elephant (
  • Spiced Cub Chai Latte $3.65/$3.95 (V) (GF)

                   Rio  spiced chai with your milk choice

  • Queen Anne $3.50/$3.75

                   Earl Grey Tea, vanilla flavored milk on top

  • Matcha Latte $3.65/$3.

                   Matcha green tea, milk choice, 

                  lightly flavored with vanilla

Frappes and Smoothies

16oz/20oz/24oz

Everything is better blended!

  • Plain Frappe $4.25/$4.95/$5.95
    • Liquid ice-cream, ice, and coffee blended and topped with whipped cream
  • Smoothies $3.65/$3.95/$4.35
    • Strawberry, mango, strawberry banana, or mixed berry
  • Peanut Butter Mocha Frappe $4.75/$5.10/$5.75
  • Liquid ice-cream, ice, mocha, peanut butter, and coffee all blended together and topped with whipped cream
  • Oreo Frappe $4.75/$5.05/$6.05
    • Liquid ice-cream, ice, espresso, and Oreo cookies blended together and topped with whipped cream

Addins and Extras

Flavor Shots: 0.50/each

  • Caramel sauce
  • Mocha sauce
  • White Mocha sauce
  • Hazelnut
  • Caramel
  • French vanilla
  • Almond
  • Cinnamon
  • Coconut
  • Irish Cream
  • Ginger
  • Praline
  • Amaretto
  • Sugar-free Vanilla
  • Sugar-free Caramel

Milk Substitutions: (all drinks are made with 2% dairy milk unless specified)

  • Almond  +.75
  • Oat +.95


Breakfast Menu

Start your morning off right! We offer great tasting, healthy food with choices for everyone! Any Breakfast Sandwich can be made as a wrap! Just specify when ordering!

Suzy B Steak Breakfast Sandwich

6.00

Egg, Onions, Roasted Red Peppers, Mozzarella, Thin-shaved Steak, and 1872 Breakfast Sauce on choice of bread.

Freddie D Veggie Breakfast Sandwich

5.50

Egg, Cheddar, Onion, Spinach, Tomato, and 1872 Breakfast Sauce on choice of bread.

Classic Breakfast Sandwich

5.50

Choice of Turkey Bacon, Pork Sausage, or Ham with Egg, Cheddar, and 1872 Breakfast Sauce on choice of bread.

Belgian Waffle

6.95

Made to order every time! Out light, tasty waffles have a touch of cinnamon and are a warm treat!


  • Add Seasonal Fresh Fruit +$1.00
  • Add Egg Soufflé and Turkey Bacon +3.50

Sausage, Egg, and Cheese Breakfast Pizza

3.25 Slice or 12.95 Whole

Our Traditional 14'' pizza with real eggs, cheddar, mozzarella cheeses, and the freshest ingredients, cooked to perfection.

Single Slices only available from 7am to 11 am.

Turkey Bacon, Egg, and Cheese Breakfast Pizza

3.25 Slice or 12.95 Whole

 Our Traditional 14'' pizza with real eggs, cheddar, mozzarella cheeses, and the freshest ingredients, cooked to perfection. 

Single Slices only available from 7am to 11am

Popeye's Spinach Breakfast Pizza

3.25 Slice or 12.95 Whole

 Our Traditional 14'' pizza with real eggs, ricotta and mozzarella cheeses, and spinach.

Single Slices only available from 7am to 11am.

Meatlover's Breakfast Pizza

Whole only 12.95

Our 14'' traditional pizza with real eggs, turkey bacon, sausage, steak, and mozzarella and cheddar cheeses.

Veggie Lover's Breakfast PIzza

3.25 Slice or 12.95 Whole

Our 14'' traditional pizza with real eggs, banana peppers, spinach, mushrooms, and mozzarella and cheddar cheeses.

Donuts

Single: $1.40

Half Dozen: $7.95

Dozen: $12.95


*Does not include apple fritters

Assorted Bagels

1.95

Call store to check selection of flavors for the day. 


Can be toasted and buttered upon request.


Cream Cheese +0.75

Jumbo Muffins

2.25 each

Choice of Chocolate Chip, Blueberry Crumb, or Banana Nut.

BYO Omlet- The Lower Carb Option

5.50

2 Egg Omlet with choice of 3 Items inside! Add any additional items or egg for only +0.75.


  • Ham
  • Sausage
  • Turkey Bacon
  • Steak
  • Mushrooms
  • Banana Peppers
  • Onions
  • Spinach
  • Tomato
  • Jalapeno
  • Roasted Red Peppers
  • Mozzarella Cheese
  • Cheddar Cheese


Vegan/Gluten Free Menu

All of our Vegan/Gluten Free Items!

Good Day Rosa Breakfast Sandwich

5.50

Seasoned Tofu, Spinach, Red Onion, Tomato, and Hummus. Spread on toasted bread of choice.


Add Vegan cheese: +0.75

Veggie Wrap

7.75

Seasoned Tofu, Spinach, Hummus, Vegan Cheese, Tomatoes, and onion on choice of wrap.


Spinach Wrap, White Grain Wrap, Gluten Free Wrap

Veggie Burger

7.75

 Vegan Veggie Burger, Toasted roll, Hummus spread, Vegan Mayo,  Spinach, Tomato, and Onion.

 

Add Vegan Cheese +0.75 

Vegan/Gluten Free Pizza

Whole Only 14.99

11'' Personal Size Cauliflower pizza crust, Robust tomato sauce, and Vegan cheese.



Additional Toppings +2.00/each

Taste of Supreme Desserts

Varies on Item

Stop in to see our loaded cooler filled with gluten free and vegan treats!

3 Bean Chili

4.50/7.50

Our house-made 3 bean chili topped with vegan cheese. 


Served WEDNESDAYS only.


Soup and Salad

Homemade Soups and Garden Fresh Salads

Chicken and Rice Soup

3.95/6.95

Soups are made in house and selection changes daily! Call the store to inquire about flavor of the day. 



Creamy Tomato Basil Soup

3.95/6.95

Fresh whole tomatoes, cream and basil blended together, better than mom's (Sorry, Mom!) . Perfect for a cold day, or with a sandwich. 

New England Style Clam Chowder

4.50/7.50

Oven roasted potatoes, carrots, and celery. Lots of whole clams, and a thick creamy chowder base--house made.  **Gluten Free**



Chicken and Shrimp Gumbo with Rice

4.50/7.50

New Orleans  style gumbo with chicken, sausage, and shrimp served with white rice.

3 Bean Vegan Chili

4.50/7.50

Thick and  hearty chili made with kidney beans, black beans, and navy beans. Stewed with diced tomatoes and seasoned to perfection, not too spicy! Topped with cheese. 

**Gluten Free**



Quart of Soup

12.99

Must have 24 hr notice. Any soup on menu is available as a quart.


For chowder/gumbo add $2.

Soup and Salad Special

7.75

A cup of soup and a small salad. The perfect lunch.

Garden Salad

3.75/6.75

Romaine lettuce, Spring Mix, Tomato, Onion, Cucumber, and Carrots. 


Choice of Dressing:

  • Italian
  • Balsamic
  • Raspberry Vinaigrette
  • Ranch
  • Bleu Cheese

1872 Grilled Chicken Salad

8.00

Our garden salad topped with grilled chicken and cheddar cheese. Choice of dressing.

Shrimp and Grits

7.50/10.50

Seasoned grits topped with shrimp in a zesty butter sauce.


Small comes with 5-6 shrimp

Large comes with 10 Shrimp

AVAILABLE ONLY THURSDAY-SUNDAY


**Gluten Free**


Sandwiches

Available Bread Choices: Assorted Bagel, Italian Sub Roll, Croissant, Ciabatta Bread, Herbed Focaccia, Sandwich Thin, White Wrap, Spinach Wrap, Gluten Free Wrap +1.00, Gluten Free Bread +1.00

"1872" Cheese Panini

5.75

Choice of Cheddar, American, Swiss, Provolone, or Mozzarella cheese.


 

Free Add-ons: Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Italian Dressing

+0.50 Add-ons: Banana Peppers, Roasted Red Peppers, Spinach, Mushrooms

The "Freddie-Sue" Tuna

7.00

Seasoned Albacore Tuna with Mayo and diced onions. Served toasted with choice of cheese.


 

Free Add-ons: Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Italian Dressing

+0.50 Add-ons: Banana Peppers, Roasted Red Peppers, Spinach, Mushrooms

Landmark Buffalo Chicken Wrap

7.50

Grilled chicken with buffalo sauce, bleu cheese dressing, spinach, tomatoes, andbanana peppers on a wrap and toasted. 

The Main Street Turkey Sub

6.50/9.50

White Meat Turkey, Choice of Cheese, Dressing.


Free Add-ons: Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Italian Dressing


+0.50 Add-ons: Banana Peppers, Roasted Red Peppers, Spinach, Mushrooms

The Downtown Steak Sub

7.50/10.75

Shaved Philly Style Steak, caramelized onions, roasted red peppers, mozzarella on a toasted roll with boss sauce.


 

Free Add-ons: Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Italian Dressing

+0.50 Add-ons: Banana Peppers, Roasted Red Peppers, Spinach, Mushrooms

The 1872 Burger

7.75

All Beef Seasoned Burger, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mayo, Ketchup all on a toasted Ciabatta roll.


Add cheese: +0.50

BBQ Burger

9.50

All Beef Seasoned Burger, Lettuce, Tomato, Crispy Fried Onions, Turkey Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, and Sal's Birdland BBQ Sauce, on a toasted Ciabatta roll.

Grilled Chicken Sandwich

7.75

Grilled White Meat Chicken Breast, Toasted Ciabatta roll, Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onions, and Boss Sauce.


Pizza

Fresh pizzas, fresh ingredients, and crispy thin crust.

Pizza by the Slice

Mozzarella Slice 2.75

Pepperoni Slice 3.25

Specialty Slice, varies daily 3.25

Traditional 14' Pizza

9.50

Our thin crust style pizza, delicious red sauce, and lots of mozzarella!


Artisan Thin Crust

12.50

Premium 16'' Artisan dough, delicious red sauce, and lots of mozzarella!

Traditional Sheet Crust Pizza

13.99

Thick Style crust, 15 Slices, red sauce, and mozzarella.

Toppings

  • Double Cheese
  • Pepperoni
  • Sausage
  • Turkey Bacon
  • Ham
  • Steak
  • Grilled Chicken
  • Roasted Red Peppers
  • Tomato
  • Red Onion
  • Ricotta Cheese
  • Spinach
  • Banana Peppers
  • Mushrooms
  • Jalapeno 

14'' +$1.50/topping

16" +$2.00/topping

Half Sheet + $2.25/topping


Specailty Pizzas

14'' Pizza $15.95//16'' Pizza $17.95

Suzy B Steak Breakfast Pizza

Steak, Eggs, Roasted Red Peppers, Onions, and Mozzarella cheese.

Popeye's Spinach Breakfast Pizza

Eggs, Ricotta Cheese, Fresh Cracked Black Pepper, Spinach, and Mozzarella Cheese.

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Bleu Cheese Sauce Base, Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella Cheese, and Buffalo Sauce

Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Ranch Sauce Base, Grilled Chicken, Turkey Bacon, and Mozzarella cheese.

Hawaiian Pizza

Our house blend red tomato sauce, Ham, Pineapple, and Mozzarella Cheese.

1872 Margherita Pizza

Our house blend red tomato sauce, Spinach, Tomato, Basil, and Mozzarella Cheese.


Combos Deals

Feeling extra hungry? Feeding the family? Make it a combo!

Make It a Combo!

+2.00

Add a drink and side to your main choice!

  • 12oz Can of Soda OR 16oz Water
  • Brownie OR Chips OR Cookie OR  Fruit

Make it a Fry Combo!

+3.25

Add a small fry and 12oz drink OR 16oz Water to your main choice!

14" Pizza & 10 Wings

18.72

Our 14'' thin crust 1-topping pizza and 10 Wings

  • Wings come with choice of any Sal's Birdland Sauces.

Artisan Pizza & 10 Wings

22.00

Our 16'' Artisan crust, 1-topping pizza and 10 Wings 

  • Wings come with choice of any Sal's Birdland Sauces.

1/2 Sheet Pizza

9.99

Thick crust style "sheet pizza". 16 slices


Wings and Things

Our Wings are BAKED fresh for every order! We proudly serve SAL'S BIRDLAND SAUCES!

Wings

Choice of sauce: 

  • Sal's BBQ
  • Sal's Sassy Mild
  • Sal's Sassy Hot
  • Boss Sauce

5 Piece w/1 Bleu Cheese: 5.75

10 Piece w/2 Bleu Cheese: 10.75

20 Piece w/3 Bleu Cheese: 18.72

Thick Steak Cut Fries

2.95/5.75

Thick cut style steak fries, tossed with seasoning salt and served hot. Our fries are baked freshed for every order!

"Not Guilty" Fries

7.75

Our thick cut steak fries baked, never fried; topped with chili and cheese! (Gluten Free)



*Can be made vegan!

Mac and Cheese

5.50/8.25

Baked Mac and Cheese with Romano, Cheddar, and Mozzarella cheeses.


Add toppings: 1.50/3.00 each

  • Turkey Bacon
  • Pepperoni
  • Spinach
  • Mushroom

Meatball Cup

5.99

12oz cup all beef meatballs in our signature red sauce. Add 6'' soft Italian roll for 1.00


Sides, Desserts, and Add-ons, Oh My!

Want to add something crunchy? Sweet? Savory? to your order? Look no further!

Chips

1.00

Assorted Flavors.

Grab and Go Oatmeal Cups

1.95

Assorted flavors. Add sliced banana, peanut butter scoop, or substitute steamed milk for $1.00.

Fresh Fruit

1.00

Fresh whole fruit: Banana, Apples, Oranges

Candied Nuts

3.75

Candied Almonds with cinnamon and sugar

Cookies

2.00

Fresh baked cookies, assorted flavors

Apple Fritters

3.00

Assorted Snacks

1.25

Granola Bars, Rice Rollers, Biscotta, Banana Bread Squares, Brownies

Parfaits, Fruit Cups, Veggie Cups

4

Cheese and Pepperoni

3.00

Cheese cubes, pepperoni, and crackers.

Cans of Soda

1.05

Pepsi Products

1 Liter Bottles

2.05

Pepsi Products

Red Bull

3.00

Regular and Sugar Free options available.

*Our kitchen is not gluten-free, but extra care is taken with any Gluten free orders!

Copyright © 2019 1812 Cafe - All Rights Reserved.


Powered by GoDaddy Website Builder

Order Now

Already know what you want to eat? Click below!

Order Online